Look at the other options. It couldn't have been that either of the other two wolf teams refused to vote at all. Of the two teams that failed to vote, one was in the same clue, and the other was the safe sheep.
If you're suggesting that one of the wolves voted against their own, in the first ousting, when we were all very uncertain of our suspicions... I would say that's very unlikely. The voting ended in a tie; they would have nearly doomed their own. All of the Lockhart/Springfield votes went in the order of the Judge, who we know was a sheep, then your partner Ms. Lucina... Mr. Dandy, who brought that team up to a 3 to 3 tie, and Detective Gumshoe, who brought that team into the majority of 4 to 3... until Ms. L'Arachel voted the other way and brought it back to a tie.
no subject
If you're suggesting that one of the wolves voted against their own, in the first ousting, when we were all very uncertain of our suspicions... I would say that's very unlikely. The voting ended in a tie; they would have nearly doomed their own. All of the Lockhart/Springfield votes went in the order of the Judge, who we know was a sheep, then your partner Ms. Lucina... Mr. Dandy, who brought that team up to a 3 to 3 tie, and Detective Gumshoe, who brought that team into the majority of 4 to 3... until Ms. L'Arachel voted the other way and brought it back to a tie.